You cannot compact PST file data without opening Outlook because Microsoft documents Compact Now inside Outlook only. Five methods give Mailbox Cleanup, Compact Now, background compaction, a second PST file and repair software. Methods 1 to 4 need Outlook open. Repair software saves your mail in EML or MSG while Outlook is closed but does not compact the file. Backup the file and scan a copy first.
You want to compact a PST file and your data file remains the same size after you delete mail. Microsoft explains the steps in an article on reducing the size of mailbox and data files and says the file does not always shrink on its own.
This guide explains five ways to shrink the data file and what to do when Outlook does not start.
Why You Cannot Compact PST File to a Smaller Size
Microsoft pages name four reasons:
- Deleted Items. Microsoft says a large Deleted Items folder is a common cause of a large data file.
- Unused white space. Microsoft says Outlook compacts a file in the background only when more than 20 percent of it is unused space.
- Large messages. Microsoft suggests a search for
messagesize:>5 mbto find big messages. - Cache size. Shared mailbox caches grow to 70 to 80 GB in large organizations.
Microsoft says you do not need to close Outlook for Compact Now. Step still needs Outlook to be open.
Which Method Matches Your File?
Find the closest situation in the first column:
| Situation | Likely Cause | Begin With |
|---|---|---|
| Deleted Items folder is large | Mail kept after deletion | Method #1 |
| File size is unchanged after cleanup | Unused white space | Method #2 |
| You want no manual step | Background compaction | Method #3 |
| Old mail is not needed daily | Too much mail in one file | Method #4 |
| Outlook does not start | Mail needs a copy outside Outlook | Method #5 |
5 Ways to Compact PST File Without Opening Outlook
Microsoft documents methods 1 to 4 and all four need Outlook. Method 5 works while Outlook is closed:
| Fix | Needs Outlook |
|---|---|
| Mailbox Cleanup and Deleted Items | Yes |
| Compact Now | Yes |
| Background compaction | Yes |
| Move items to another PST | Yes |
| Scan and export | Not for EML and MSG |
Method #1: Empty Deleted Items and Delete Large Messages (Free)
Microsoft lists cleanup before any compaction. Five steps follow:
- Delete mail you do not need.
- Go to File, Tools and Mailbox Cleanup.
- Select View Deleted Items Size then Empty Deleted Items.
- Type
messagesize:>5 mbin the search box. - Delete or move the large messages that appear.
Note: Microsoft says you can also use Conversation Clean Up to remove redundant messages from long threads.
Method #2: Use Compact Now to Compact PST File (Free)
Microsoft gives this path for PST and OST files. Step takes several minutes and needs no Outlook restart. Six steps follow:
- Empty the Deleted Items folder.
- Open File, Account Settings and Account Settings again.
- Click the Data Files tab and select the file.
- Click Settings.
- Choose Compact Now and click OK.
- Wait for Outlook to finish.
Note: Microsoft adds a step for Exchange and Outlook.com accounts. Click the Advanced tab then Outlook Data File Settings before Compact Now.
Method #3: Let Outlook Compact PST File in the Background (Free)
Microsoft says Outlook compacts the file during idle time after you delete items. Four steps follow:
- Delete items and empty Deleted Items.
- Keep Outlook open and idle for a while.
- Check the file size in File Explorer later.
- Use Method #2 if the size is unchanged.
Note: Microsoft ties this to more than 20 percent unused white space in the file.
Method #4: Move Old Mail to Another PST File (Free)
Microsoft suggests deleting large messages or moving them to another PST file. Archiving old mail and deleting large attachments adds more space. Five steps follow:
- Search for large messages with
messagesize:>5 mb. - Create a new Outlook data file under New Items and More Items.
- Drag the old or large mail into the new file.
- Empty Deleted Items in the first file.
- Use Method #2 on the first file.
Note: An OST is a cache and Outlook rebuilds it from the server.
Method #5: Save the Mail With EmailDoctor Outlook PST Repair Tool (Trial Limit Applies)
EmailDoctor Outlook PST Repair Tool scans a PST file and exports its mail without Outlook. Software does not compact the file but saves the mail in a new place. You rebuild a smaller file from that mail.
EML, PDF, HTML and MSG exports work without Outlook. PST export needs Outlook with the Use Outlook option. Scan a copy of the file only.
Scan the Large PST Copy
Three actions scan the copy:
- Install the repair software on Windows and open it.
- Click Add File and locate the large PST copy.
- Choose how to scan and start.
Select the Mail and Export
Three more actions save the mail:
- Browse the folder tree and tick the folders you need.
- Click Export and select EML or MSG while Outlook is closed.
- Name a destination folder and begin the export.
Note: EmailDoctor software exports 25 items per folder in the trial version. Buying a license removes the limitation.
What Size Did You Get?
Compare your result with these rows:
| Outcome | Verdict | Method |
|---|---|---|
| Deleted Items is empty and the file is smaller | Mail was held in Deleted Items | Method #1 |
| File shrinks after Compact Now | White space was the cause | Method #2 |
| File shrinks after an idle period | Background compaction worked | Method #3 |
| First file is smaller after the move | Too much mail in one file | Method #4 |
| Outlook does not start | Mail needs a copy outside Outlook | Method #5 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Compact PST File Without Opening Outlook?
No. Microsoft documents Compact Now inside Outlook only. Repair software saves the mail without Outlook but does not compact the file.
Does Compact Now Delete My Mail?
No. Microsoft describes Compact Now as a step that removes unused space after you delete items. Backup the file before you start.
Does the Trial Version of EmailDoctor Software Export Every Folder?
No. EmailDoctor software exports 25 items per folder in the trial version. Buying a license removes the limitation.
Why Does My File Not Shrink After I Delete Mail?
Outlook compacts the file in the background only when more than 20 percent of the file is unused space. Start Compact Now by hand when the size is unchanged.
How Long Does It Take to Compact PST File?
Microsoft says Compact Now takes several minutes. Large files can take longer.
Can I Delete an OST File to Reduce Its Size?
OST is an offline cache and Outlook recreates it. Rename the file instead of deleting it so that you keep a copy.
Author’s Verdict
Every method to compact PST file data needs Outlook according to Microsoft. Empty Deleted Items first because that removes the most space.
Use Compact Now when the size is unchanged and backup the file before you start. Move old mail to a second file when one file contains too much.
Choose repair software when Outlook will not open and you need the mail. Export to EML or MSG first and rebuild a smaller file afterward.
- Microsoft documents how to compact PST file data with Compact Now inside Outlook.
- Deleted Items and white space are the main causes of a large PST file.
- Repair software saves the mail while Outlook is closed and does not compact the file.